← back to list

Held hostage by a high performer

★ signal-weak   r/smallbusiness  ·  ↑ 244  ·  💬 286  ·  2026-04-21  ·  kw: too much time  ·  open on reddit ↗
your rating:
Tool
none
Issue
Healthcare receptionist resists new business processes introduced by partner; resistance disrupts team morale and operational efficiency despite reassurance, lifetime contract offer, and process improvements that objectively reduce her workload.
Cost
unstated
Recommendation
Change management approach: (1) informal social bonding between receptionist and new partner; (2) actively solicit receptionist's input on new systems and process design; (3) weekly 15-min check-ins to discuss automation concerns and gather suggestions; (4) position receptionist as leader of new system rollout to restore sense of control and value; (5) if resistance persists after engagement, consider termination.
Date context
2026-04-21; update indicates resolution via paid leave and severance as employee pursued retirement due to health issues
extracted with
anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5 · 2026-05-08

Body

Here's the short version of what's going on: I have a health care business and have a high performer receptionist. Patients love her and doctors love her too. She's great and works like a well oiled machine. I recently brought in a business partner who bought in the business and whom I've known for a long time. He turned the business into a cash cow. He has great character, very respectful and trustworthy. She didn't like it, because he wanted things done his way, which isn't adding more work load for her. It's in fact making her job easier. She likes the old ways and is very resistant to change. We suspect she may have paranoia about her losing her job. We reassured her and even offered her a lifetime contract and pretty much a guarantee she won't be fired until she quits or retires. Full benefits package and paid vacation days. But it's not working and we don't get it. They keep fighting and it's affecting the mood in the business. She's been with us since the beginning and we love her and don't want to let go and she carries our business, as the receptionist in a healthcare business is what makes or breaks the business. We could start looking for new receptionists but we are afraid we can't find someone like her. Have you been in this situation before? And what do you suggest we do? UPDATE : Thank you all for your contributions and advice. I did as some of you suggested and sat down with her to discuss this matter and brought up ownership, appreciation and fears of loss of control. She was very candid and disclosed that she felt her role may not be as important as it is going forward. We reassured her that she is still the backbone of our business and pledged nothing will change other than the changes we have made. She said she isn't feeling well and her heart is failing and needs surgery soon and she will take time off and think about retirement. We gave her paid time off until the end of the year and a generous severance package in case she quits and left the door open for her to come back. She was grateful and offered to stay to train more staff until they're ready. We are happy with the results and feel this is resolved. Even if we paid her for the next 10 years to stay at home it wouldn't repay how much she helped us grow the past years.

Top comments (5)

[score=1] AutoModerator
**Friendly Reminder** r/smallbusiness is a question and answer subreddit. Ask a question about starting, owning, and growing a small business and the community answers. Posts that violate the rules listed in the sidebar will be removed. **Please do not conduct market research on our community.** We are not your focus group and asking us about our pain points, needs, what is hardest about X, etc. is not asking about how small business works or for real help with running your small business. These posts are subject to removal and given the community's disgust with the constant spamming of these posts you might just destroy your brand and contaminate your company search results. Seeing this message does not mean your post was automatically removed. If you asked about pain points or are directly or indirectly promoting a product please remove your post. Come back to post an honest question or give a knowledgeable response to someone else's question and leave your company name in your own profile. We can tell if you know what you're doing and the community can reach out if they need to. **We welcome honest question posts, especially from newcomers.** Thank you for your post. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/smallbusiness) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[score=226] DapperEbb4180
Can you give a specific example or examples of things she has been asked to do but won’t? What does “done his way” mean?
[score=72] TT-Bear29
I’ve run a few businesses in my lifetime and what this may be is insecurity on the employees part. Part of the problem may have been a lack of consideration of the change management required to bring the employees (including your receptionist) on the journey to get stakeholder buy in. It’s not too late but if we assume the damage has already been done, it may be best to try to have a final heart to heart, let them know they are a valued member and that your ideal scenario is for them to stay - showing her the benefits (and results) of the new ways may help. As someone else has already said, unfortunately if after that they still aren’t supportive and the changes have objectively benefited the organisation it may be best to let them go. Wishing you all the best. People are always the trickiest and most rewarding parts of running a business
[score=25] Odd_Construction_269
I’m a healthcare manager!! I’ve run into this. The automation may not be trusted yet, and if patients have questions about it she’s the first one who has to help. She doesn’t tell you the manager everything. 😃 I suggest making a weekly check in specifically for 15 min to discuss the system and for her to be permitted to bring suggestions on how to improve it. You don’t know if she’s getting complaints, helping with a population who may not be benefiting like you think, etc. I think if you and the business partner let her lead the charge on running this and put it under her responsibilities, she’ll stay!!!! Acknowledge pros and cons you see with the system, ask her for suggestions on fixing the cons :) In seasons of automation, we have to really remind employees of their value and expertise. Let them OWN the automation and vendor relationship. 😀
[score=87] timeforacatnap852
I’m a former Coo, 4x exits, 3 were VC backed. I’ve run teams as small as 2 and as big as 60. I’ve seen this case happen a few times. Recommended action 1. Have new guy meet with and have informal “social hang out” with receptionist, aim is to get each to know the other on a Human level… some kind of team building will help this 2. Have new guy welcome and actively ask the advice and help of receptionist - “hey receptionist, I heard from the team how important and valuable you are, and your title doesn’t simply reflect all of your role, these are things I’m planning, I would love your opinion on what to add, change, keep, what might I be missing as we build this? 3. Ensure new guy knows full well the value of receptionist and how receptionist title is not reflective of how much bigger her role is 4. Provide a career progression path for receptionist