← back to list

Why Does This Sub Suck Lately? (Moderator Update)

· noise   r/shopify  ·  ↑ 105  ·  💬 59  ·  2026-03-27  ·  kw: hours every day  ·  open on reddit ↗
your rating:
Tool
none
Issue
Ecommerce subreddits (r/Shopify, r/Ecommerce, r/Etsy) are overwhelmed by AI-generated bot posts using stealth marketing tactics disguised as community questions, with posts following recognizable patterns (two-part titles, ending with 'curious' phrasing, followed by coordinated responses recommending paid services), forcing moderators to manually remove compliant content and lowering report thresholds from 10 to 3 to combat the volume.
Cost
unstated
Recommendation
strict moderation, karma and account age limits, community reporting, reward brands with honest expertise sharing instead of stealth marketing (none)
Date context
as of 2026-03-27; Reddit detection tools described as inadequate; moderation threshold lowered from 10 to 3 reports within the past day
extracted with
anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5 · 2026-05-08

Body

I am posting this in both r/Ecommerce and r/Shopify as we share some of the same mod team (including myself) and this applies to both subs equally. Basing my title off a great post from a few weeks ago by u/legrolls and expanding a bit. These groups (and many, many others) are under attack from bots and AI accounts, and mods are overwhelmed. Two days ago, I banned an account that actually posted the prompt he put into AI for a post that would generate lots of feedback and be able to get around the blacklisted terms (yes, they actually posted the prompt...). This week we have increased both the post and comment requirements in both subs, and we also share a comprehensive blacklist of auto-remove terms (there are well over a hundred of them). It seems like every day we face the 'can't mods do anything about these obvious AI posts?' and we can, with your help. Reddit has improved their detection tools, but that isn't saying much. I personally have begun removing posts that otherwise comply with our rules, but just simply 'look' suspect. There are some signs of these - - Post title is usually 2-part, such as 'Our site was bleeding visitors for years. Here is what fixed it'. - The post itself is just a few paragraphs, which may or may not contain bullet points. It almost always ends with a question to the community (no doubt to try to get feedback). - The post will be responded to (but not immediately, usually even a day later) with a different user recommending the perfect service that now fixes this problem. - The question at the end almost always has 'curious' in the wording (curious what others are doing about this...). - Other giveaway signs are the usual 'hyphen' issue, the term 'move the needle', the word 'kindly', and just how the formatting is exactly the same for nearly all such posts. - The accounts are most often made by burner accounts named with the 'word-word-number' formula. They are years-old accounts but a huge gap in posting; usually years since their first posts, but now they are suddenly active. Our groups specifically (r/Shopify and r/Ecommerce) are now *the* recommended groups by AI for users to try to post their ecom-related services (I have seen the AI responses on this - they literally tell users to post in these popular subs). So yeah, we are under attack. My appeal is for **all** users of these groups to assume mod duties. As of yesterday, the threshold for auto-removal of a post or comment due to reports has been lowered from 10 to 3. The 'report' button is our best weapon until Reddit figures out a better way to combat this. Lastly, be patient with the moderators - we can't and won't find them all. We have a great and active group of mods who truly care about these subs, and most have been here quite a while (over 14 years in my own case). I have never seen anything like what we are seeing now, and we need the action of the entire community of users to try to keep this focused on *real* content from *real* users. We clearly aren't in Kansas anymore...

Top comments (10)

[score=20] wartortlechortle
Mod for r/Etsy here. We are seeing the exact same thing in r/Etsy and in r/EtsySellers as well, with egregious posts that start out as "What is a problem you're trying to solve with your shop?" and inevitably is some kind of AI promo for a tool or app. Thank you to everybody in all subs that report these kinds of slop posts. It's an annoying time to try to help people in e-commerce spaces. I believe r/EtsySellers has a rule that specifically forbids market research posts as well.
[score=13] Ok-Parsnip-3276
Yeah honestly, it’s getting quite annoying, will keep an eye out for it, cheers
[score=9] olapbill
Happy to report em in both subs
[score=6] Vintranada
Thanks for taking the right steps forward. Appreciate all your efforts.
[score=5] imaginary_name
Because agentic posting and stealth marketing are rampant all over the place. Any literate person now can slap together a solution to monitor subs and reply to percieved "leads". The only thing that works is strict moderation, karma and account age limits, and rewarding brands that talk to users honestly, openly, share expertise with wider audience, don't use stealth marketing practices. Sharing expertise with everyone, not just with my ICP is my shtick. I have layered motivation to say this, because I am not only a reddit user frustrated by bots and stealth marketers, but I am also in consultative role in software sales in the ecommerce/seo space.
[score=4] soulchild_
Thank you for your efforts on moderating this sub, I will try my best to do my part on reporting suspicious posts 🙏 (yes they follow the formula you have mentioned, they always starts with a fake complaint and at the end "curiously" asking feedback)
[score=3] pjmg2020
🫡
[score=3] John___Matrix
Thanks! It must be a nightmare these days, so much AI slop everywhere.
[score=3] navdeep-soni
And this is gonna increase.. tough times ahead
[score=3] Major-Warthog8067
It's in every subreddit that could be monetized. I just want to talk about business and ecommerce related stuff. I have also seen sob stories about failing brand and "going out of business" type sale gaining traction recently in another small business subreddit. At first I thought it was genuine, but over few weeks I noticed the same format was used by others to sell different things.