← back to list

My Google Ads Search Campaign Tanked After Years of Success – Any Insight?

★★★ signal-strong   r/ppc  ·  ↑ 140  ·  💬 40  ·  2025-05-24  ·  kw: hours every day  ·  open on reddit ↗
your rating:
Tool
Google Ads, ChatGPT Pro with Operator
Issue
Service-based business experienced sudden campaign collapse in 2025: impressions vanished, CPC increased from $6–8 to $42–54 per click, and phone leads dried up despite 2 years of stable 2–4 jobs/week performance; new campaign from scratch showed identical failure pattern.
Cost
$17,000 weekly revenue loss (pre-recovery); $42–54 CPC vs. historical $6–8 CPC represents 5–9x cost inflation per conversion
Recommendation
Local Service Ads (LSA) setup with exact-match keywords and geographic modifiers (disputed — user reported LSA yielded $210/call with junk leads); aggressive negative keyword management for competitor searches; target CPA bidding instead of Max Conversions; manual campaign control; account audit by third party; diversify across SEO, Meta, Microsoft Ads, and traditional marketing
Date context
early 2025 algorithm changes; Google recently shifted to favor LSA over traditional search for local services; user applied GPT-4.5 with Operator agent on 2025-05-24 with immediate recovery
extracted with
anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5 · 2026-05-08

Body

Hey everyone, I run a service-based business in NYC focused on indoor air quality testing (mold, VOCs, etc.), and my entire business has been built on Google Ads search campaigns. I don’t have a storefront – just a couple of employees, a solid service, and a phone number. Here’s the rundown: **The Backstory** When I started a few years ago, I knew very little – learned from YouTube, tried things out. Somehow I created a search campaign that worked. * 6–7 clicks a day * $6–$8 CPC * 1–3 phone calls a day * Booked 2–4 jobs a week This kept my business running smoothly for two years. I hired people. Life was good. **The Problem** In 2025, everything fell apart. Without any major changes, impressions vanished, CPC shot up to **$42 per click**, and conversions died. I paused that campaign, created a brand new one from scratch – same targeting, new ads – and the exact same thing happened: * Barely any impressions * CPC still sky-high * Leads dried up I rely almost entirely on inbound search traffic. Referrals help, but they’re not reliable – this is a one-and-done type service. You don’t need a mold test every week. My market is NYC, so demand should always exist. # What I’ve Tried * Rebuilt campaign from scratch * Tested new keywords and ad copy * Adjusted bidding strategies (Maximize Conversions) * Monitored quality scores and ad relevance (everything looked fine) # What I Don’t Understand * Why would a historically consistent campaign suddenly stop delivering? * Why would a new campaign, in a massive market like NYC, get almost no traffic? * Has something changed in Google’s system recently that favors big-budget or lead form campaigns? I’m honestly at a loss. This is how I feed my employees and pay rent. If anyone’s experienced this drop-off recently or has thoughts, I’d really appreciate some guidance or just to know I’m not going crazy. Thanks in advance. **Update:** First of all—massive thanks to everyone who commented on my original post. The advice, sympathy, and even just the “yeah dude, Google Ads is a black box now” validation helped more than you know. So after a week of *nothing*—no calls, no leads, just CPCs spiking to $54 and me paying my crew out of pure delusion—I was cooked. Burnt. Done. Sitting at my desk like a monkey staring at a glowing rectangle wondering why my life is now entirely dependent on an algorithm I don’t understand. Then I remembered I have ChatGPT Pro. And this thing called *Operator*. I was like, “You know what? I’m already getting zero calls so before i pay an agency let’s see what happens if I just let the AI do it. This campaign is already wrecked anyway. So I copy-pasted this prompt I built using GPT-4.5 and Reddit threads and deep reaserchj based on this, logged in through Operator, guide it to log in gave it my Google Ads credentials (yes, I know, probably insane), and told it: “Do whatever you want. Break shit. Edit anything. I literally do not care anymore.” And this thing *went to town*. For 27 straight minutes it was like watching a hacker movie in real-time. It removed 47 negative keywords, added new keywords, changed some to phrase some to broad match, adjusted targeting, restructured some ad groups, and scrolled through settings I forgot even existed. Every 30 seconds it would ask something like “Do you want me to change this?” and I finally just said: “STOP ASKING. YOU ARE GOD NOW.” Then it stopped. Said “all done.” I figured it was about to get my account banned or implode my credit card. **Next day, I get 4 phone calls.** Three scheduled jobs. One from a luxury retail store in SoHo. Another from a hotel needing 12 rooms tested. A few solid residentials. CPC dropped from $42 to **$7.96**. And it’s stayed there all week. The week before? **$0**. This week? **Booked $17K.** What even is reality anymore? Anyway, I’m working on diversifying channels now because I’m not trying to let one algorithm decide whether I eat next month. But for now—holy shit. We’re back.

Top comments (10)

[score=31] QuantumWolf99
This exact pattern hit several of my local service clients in early 2025... it's likely tied to Google's recent algorithm changes that heavily favor LSA over traditional search campaigns. Google has been systematically pushing service businesses toward LSA and away from search ads... they make more money from LSA fees plus your ad spend. For air quality testing specifically, I've seen CPCs triple because Google knows it's a high-value service where businesses will pay premium rates. Two immediate fixes that have worked for similar service clients... first, get LSA set up immediately since Google now prioritizes LSA results over search ads for local services. Second, try exact match keywords with very specific geographic modifiers like "mold testing manhattan" instead of broader terms. The brutal reality is that Google is essentially forcing local service businesses into their LSA ecosystem... but combining LSA with targeted search campaigns often restores that steady lead flow you had before. Just expect to pay more for the same results than you did two years ago.
[score=11] Hop2thetop_Dont_Stop
There are changes algo wise which you have to navigate, and like the other(s) mentioned, you should be sure to get included in LSA (local service ads) if they are active for your market. As for your PPC, one thing that has been killing ROI on a lot of local PPC accounts are competitors searches. Google has been going super aggressive with trying to make you pay for each other's brand names. They want you paying for your competitor's names, and vice versa. So make sure to aggressively add negative keywords for all competitor's searches. This means you need to review your "search terms" report and apply negatives based on that information. This is CRITICAL. Max conversions, and any smart bidding strategy tends to only exacerbate the issue. At our agency we are using tCPA/Max CVR for less competitive spaces but in the most competitive markets we are still using manual CPC, and many times manual CPC is working better than smart bidding. It just depends and is something you should continue to test. Generally broad match and pmax are terrible ideas, so don't use either of those. Pmax does not work for lead gen at the moment. I made a bunch of videos on these subjects on my channel if you want to learn more or DM me if you want me to audit your account free of charge.
[score=7] Reasonable_Mark_747
**Appreciate all the feedback here — seriously helpful. Quick update based on what a bunch of you brought up:** I actually **used LSAs years ago** alongside my regular Google Search campaign. Back then, I was paying **$50–60/day** and getting **2 solid calls a day** from Search. But LSA? I got charged **$210 per call** — most of them junk. People looking for stuff at Home Depot, or calls completely off-target. So I **paused LSA entirely** because the quality was garbage and cost was sky-high. Fast forward to now: I figured I’d give LSA another shot to see if things had improved after 3 years. I've had it **enabled for over a month — zero calls**. Not one. It's live, verified, budget is active, but nothing. Either I did something wrong in the setup (which I doubt — I double-checked everything), or it’s just **not delivering in my niche**. I also tried **Performance Max** and **Smart Bidding**… total waste. My market (indoor air quality, mold testing) is specific and local, so I went back to a **simple Search campaign — no Display, no Search Partners**, just phrase and exact match targeting. I’m in **NYC** and yeah, there’s competition — always has been — but my target area is massive and nuanced (residential + commercial, 8M+ population). I’m based nearby and can be on-site in 25 minutes, so proximity isn’t the issue either. I tried going hard on **negative keywords** (like 550+) but it ended up **choking impressions**, so I rolled some back and started seeing life again. Microsoft Ads? Tried it. Budget’s tiny. Still got calls from 5 hours away, even though I geo-targeted NYC. Bottom line: I’m still in this endless loop of tweaking, testing, pausing, rebuilding, trying to find what used to just *work*. It’s wild how upside-down things have gotten. Appreciate the offers for audits and the advice about diversifying. This thread’s been more valuable than most agency calls I’ve had.
[score=10] Flashy-Office-6852
I would be interested in knowing what you Auction insights report says before and after these changes. Did a few big businesses move into your niche with big budgets. If you had very little competition before and suddenly competition moves in, you might see an increase in CPC. You mention being on Max Conversions now. What were you using before? Is your conversion tracking working properly? I'm a full time Google Ads freelancer, so I'm happy to chat more about this. I could even do a review for you if you want. Feel free to either respond to this or send me a DM. I've done lots of account reviews and I don't hold back on these. Let me know. But again, I'm happy to problem solve with you right here in the comments if you prefer.
[score=10] lardparty
You should have someone audit it at this point. It's too crucial to have it fail for months and months while you test new things. Get a few audits and see if there really is something "wrong".
[score=4] learn_to_trade
That’s not really surprising, a lot of things change over time. People search differently, new competitors pop up, and other factors come into play. I’d definitely check the search volume, especially since search trends shift. Also, take a look at the campaign and ad group settings.
[score=4] alfredhitchkock
More competitor,algo changes Try max impression share maybe
[score=5] Legitimate_Ad785
It could be more competitors, or it could just be that Google is charging more for the clicks. If there system believe that a click will become a conversion, they will charge u the max amount, which is why ur getting $40 cpc. As a marketer I always tell people dont ever put all ur eggs in one basket, diversified ur ads, spread them between seo, meta, LSA, Microsoft, and even traditional marketing. Iv seen business who for example invested heavily on seo go out of business because they lost ranking on seo. Without looking at ur campaign we can't really tell what's ur wrong with ur campaign.
[score=5] Different-Goose-8367
Too much emphasis is put on tactics. As you saw, you managed to start a campaign and run it successfully with little knowledge. What changed for the costs to shoot up, the platform. I said this years back, if everyone is using the same bidding strategy, targeting the same kws, cpcs will go through the roof.
[score=3] theppcdude
To answer this question: # What I Don’t Understand * Why would a historically consistent campaign suddenly stop delivering? Google is doing a LOT of things behind closed doors currently. I believe having manual control over your campaigns is probably the right choice currently. Max Conversions will push your CPCs to the sky at the beginning and then stabilize. Given that you have a decent Conversion History, I would set up a tCPA campaign to lower CPCs. It takes a few rough days at the beginning sometimes but then it gets better. I run Google Ads for Service Businesses (like yours) for a living. I have a few clients that have been running ads for 10 years still have really good results with tCPA. One of these clients gets 120+ leads per month so their tCPA is dialed. I wouldn't see how it wouldn't work for you. Happy to help you in any way I can.